Skip to content
Black Friday week starts Tuesday, November 24.See the offer

In brief

Ling Lim opened a question in Client Success, about retention: I run the mentor side of an accelerator cohort solo. Sign-up is fine, but by week four the mentors go quiet and I can't tell if I'm asking too much or too little. Yong Tan's answer was accepted as the solution: Before cutting anything, where are you actually losing them? After the first 1:1, after a founder no-shows, or when cohort workload peaks? Those are different problems. 5 other replies add further detail below.

2
SolvedRetention

Mentors keep ghosting by week four

Ling Limgbeya team

I run the mentor side of an accelerator cohort solo. Sign-up is fine, but by week four the mentors go quiet and I can't tell if I'm asking too much or too little. I tried assigning each founder a lead mentor plus one monthly group session. The group session attendance stayed okay; the 1:1s died first. What's actually worth keeping?

6 answers

  • 0
    Yong Tangbeya team Accepted answer

    Before cutting anything, where are you actually losing them? After the first 1:1, after a founder no-shows, or when cohort workload peaks? Those are different problems. In our community, the highest-retention mentors weren't the ones with the tightest calendar. They were the ones who got a fifteen-minute debrief with the cohort director after each session. No form, no tracker. That small access point kept the senior mentors longer than any sync. The junior mentors wanted structured feedback, but the senior ones read that as admin. We also replaced reminder emails with a two-line personal note from the founder not the program team. So I'd separate commitment from scheduling, and probably kill the group session before the 1:1s. What did the leads say when they dropped? That answer will tell you more than the attendance sheet.

  • 0
    Noah Kinggbeya team

    Make every session the same time and day. Mentor retention is entirely a calendar problem.

  • 0
    Omondi Odhiambogbeya team

    When I ran a mentorship circle for software trainers, I recorded a four-minute video before the first session. I showed the mentee's expected pace and the two things mentors should not do. It cut first-session no-shows from twelve to four in one quarter. I didn't do much after that and the group still completed. Maybe your problem isn't keeping mentors but starting them with less confusion. What do you send before the first session?

  • 0
    Miguel Santosgbeya team

    Unpaid can work. Keep the 1:1 useful and cut the extra meeting.

  • 0
    Nadia Ashworthgbeya team

    Unpaid mentorship always decays. If retention matters, pay a token fee. Otherwise accept that mentors will ghost. We learned this the hard way with our contributor network.

  • 0
    Andrea Ramosgbeya team

    I tested a weekly recap video for my cohort. Views went up, retention didn't.

Highlights from this conversation

Answers so far

  • “Accepted answer. Before cutting anything, where are you actually losing them? After the first 1:1, after a founder no-shows, or when cohort workload peaks? Those are different problems. In our community, the highest-retention mentors weren't the ones with the tightest calendar. They were the ones who got…” Yong Tan
  • “When I ran a mentorship circle for software trainers, I recorded a four-minute video before the first session. I showed the mentee's expected pace and the two things mentors should not do. It cut first-session no-shows from twelve to four in one quarter. I didn't…” Omondi Odhiambo
  • “Unpaid mentorship always decays. If retention matters, pay a token fee. Otherwise accept that mentors will ghost. We learned this the hard way with our contributor network.” Nadia Ashworth
  • “Make every session the same time and day. Mentor retention is entirely a calendar problem.” Noah King

What to watch

  • “The junior mentors wanted structured feedback, but the senior ones read that as admin.” Yong Tan
  • “I didn't do much after that and the group still completed.” Omondi Odhiambo

Explore this topic

This question sits in Client Success, which holds 146 conversations. Helping customers succeed, stay and refer: onboarding, retention, experience, upsells and testimonials.

Related discussions

Go deeper

Reference pages that cover the practical side of this topic.

Browse every public discussion