Before cutting anything, where are you actually losing them? After the first 1:1, after a founder no-shows, or when cohort workload peaks? Those are different problems. In our community, the highest-retention mentors weren't the ones with the tightest calendar. They were the ones who got a fifteen-minute debrief with the cohort director after each session. No form, no tracker. That small access point kept the senior mentors longer than any sync. The junior mentors wanted structured feedback, but the senior ones read that as admin. We also replaced reminder emails with a two-line personal note from the founder not the program team. So I'd separate commitment from scheduling, and probably kill the group session before the 1:1s. What did the leads say when they dropped? That answer will tell you more than the attendance sheet.