Skip to content
Black Friday week starts Tuesday, November 24.See the offer

In brief

Lukas Schmidt opened a discussion in Grow, about customer acquisition: berlin, career coach here. I run a group programme that's at 14 people and I want to take it to 20. Sienna Marsden's answer was accepted as the solution: Cap the count, not the price. 4 other replies add further detail below.

6
Customer Acquisition

Group programme is full but I keep saying yes to 1:1 — how do I actually close that door?

Lukas Schmidtgbeya team

Berlin, career coach here. I run a group programme that's at 14 people and I want to take it to 20. The problem is 1:1 keeps eating the week — I have six retainer clients at €450/month who I've had for two and three years. I've raised the price once since 2021 and two of them are still on the old rate because I never had the conversation. Every time I think about pushing 1:1 out entirely I get nervous about the income dip before the group fills. But every month I keep the 1:1 I'm not out selling the group. Which one would you cut first?

5 replies

  • 11
    Maeve Fortingbeya team

    I did the opposite and honestly it worked: I kept the 1:1 but put a hard cap on the count, five max, and raised the rate for anyone new. Existing clients got grandfathered for a year, then a letter. Slow, less scary, and it kept cash coming while the group grew.

  • 19
    Sienna Marsdengbeya team Accepted answer

    Cap the count, not the price.

  • 14
    Freya Rowntreegbeya team

    What you've already got right is that you know the number — 14 to 20. Most people don't. The piece you're missing is that your 1:1 book isn't an acquisition channel, it's a retention asset, and retention assets don't get cut, they get repriced. Put a date on a calendar and tell the two old-rate clients what the new rate is from that date. They'll either stay or they won't, and either answer is information you don't currently have.

  • 17
    Lars Smitgbeya team

    Six at €450 is €2,700 a month you're scared to lose. That's not a client problem, that's a savings problem. Build the buffer, then cut.

  • 9
    Maeve Fortingbeya team

    Our group is capped at 20 and it took us nine months to get from 14 to 20. The month we stopped taking new 1:1 we had three weeks of panic and then the group filled anyway because we finally had the hours to sell it.

Highlights from this conversation

Points raised

  • “Accepted answer. Cap the count, not the price.” Sienna Marsden
  • “Six at €450 is €2,700 a month you're scared to lose. That's not a client problem, that's a savings problem. Build the buffer, then cut.” Lars Smit
  • “What you've already got right is that you know the number — 14 to 20. Most people don't. The piece you're missing is that your 1:1 book isn't an acquisition channel, it's a retention asset, and retention assets don't get cut, they get repriced. Put…” Freya Rowntree
  • “I did the opposite and honestly it worked: I kept the 1:1 but put a hard cap on the count, five max, and raised the rate for anyone new. Existing clients got grandfathered for a year, then a letter. Slow, less scary, and it kept…” Maeve Fortin

What to watch

  • “They'll either stay or they won't, and either answer is information you don't currently have.” Freya Rowntree

Explore this topic

This discussion sits in Grow, which holds 138 conversations. How clients and customers find you: acquisition channels, search, paid, social, partnerships and conversion.

Related discussions

Go deeper

Reference pages that cover the practical side of this topic.

Browse every public discussion