I've been running a paid newsletter in Rotterdam for about a year. 800 subscribers, conversion to paid is low, maybe 40 pay around €7/month. I coach people one-on-one on top of that. The issues is my calendar: I have maybe 10 discovery calls a month, 2-3 turn into clients. That's fine but fragile. When I miss two weeks of writing, the calls dry up. I'm not sure if I should be doing more outreach or fixing the funnel. What did you actually do that worked - and what did you get wrong? I don't want another rah-rah post, I want the mistakes too.
What actually worked for you to get coaching clients? Lessons, mistakes?
In brief
Eva Dekker opened a progress update in Grow, about customer acquisition: I've been running a paid newsletter in Rotterdam for about a year. 800 subscribers, conversion to paid is low, maybe 40 pay around €7/month. I coach people one-on-one on top of that. 6 replies so far. Anika Marsters says: The uncomfortable thing first: 10 discovery calls to close 2-3 is fine, but your problem isn't the funnel. It's that you're the funnel. One year in and still writing every post yourself? 5 other replies add further detail below.
6 replies
Audience: Public. Replies follow this audience.
0Anika Marstersgbeya teamProductivity Coach · Course CreatorsNew Zealand·Growing Team·1mo ago
The uncomfortable thing first: 10 discovery calls to close 2-3 is fine, but your problem isn't the funnel. It's that you're the funnel. One year in and still writing every post yourself? That doesn't scale, and you're already seeing it - miss two weeks and the calls stop. That's not a client acquisition problem, that's a delegation problem you're calling acquisition. When I hit this stage I started by hiring a part-time editor to turn my voice notes into content. It wasn't great for six months. Conversion dropped. I nearly fired her. But the calls kept coming when I got sick, which they never did before. Your real decision isn't outreach vs funnel. It's whether you're willing to let someone else be worse at your voice than you are, for a while, so the whole thing doesn't rest on your writing weeks. If the answer is no, then yes, it's fragile, and it will stay fragile. If yes, start with one piece of the process - the repurposing, the editing, the scheduling - and measure whether calls hold steady when you step back.
0Kwabena Asantegbeya teamContent Strategist · sponsorship & adsGhana·Exploring·1mo ago
Following this. I'm in a similar spot with a smaller list. Would love to hear what worked for others.
0Leo Leegbeya teamInstructional Designer · Professional Education BusinessesUnited Kingdom·Scaling·1mo ago
Have you tested a paid workshop as a step between newsletter and 1:1?
0Miguel Aquinogbeya teamFinancial Coach · paid newsletterPhilippines·Exploring·1mo ago
Just raise your prices. If the conversion is low, you're not charging enough to attract serious clients. Worked for me.
0Chebet Wanjalagbeya teamInstructional Designer · retainer consultingKenya·Scaling·1mo ago
What's your open rate and what's the offer in the newsletter?
0Anika Marstersgbeya teamProductivity Coach · Course CreatorsNew Zealand·Growing Team·1mo ago
Kwabena's question matters. If your open rate is under 30%, the issue is list quality, not funnel. If it's over 40%, then it's the offer. I'd look at where the drop-off is before changing anything.
Highlights from this conversation
What was tried
- “Have you tested a paid workshop as a step between newsletter and 1:1?” Leo Lee
- “When I hit this stage I started by hiring a part-time editor to turn my voice notes into content.” Anika Marsters
What worked
- “Would love to hear what worked for others.” Kwabena Asante
- “What did you actually do that worked - and what did you get wrong?” Eva Dekker
What to watch
- “I don't want another rah-rah post, I want the mistakes too.” Eva Dekker
- “But the calls kept coming when I got sick, which they never did before.” Anika Marsters
Explore this topic
This progress update sits in Grow, which holds 138 conversations. How clients and customers find you: acquisition channels, search, paid, social, partnerships and conversion.
Related discussions
- Client acquisition — how do you get in front of people who actually buy? · Grow · question · 5 replies · solved
I run sponsorship and ad ops for a handful of small brands, and I've built my whole pipeline on referrals so far. That's run out. I've…
- Established coach, 14 clients, but referrals have dried up — where do I actually go from here? · Grow · question · 8 replies · solved
I've been coaching full-time for about four years now, mostly career transitions for mid-career professionals. My practice grew almost entirely on referrals and it worked …
- How do you get clients when your referrals have dried up? · Grow · question · 7 replies · solved
I've been coaching productivity for six years and referrals used to just happen. Last eight months they've gone quiet and I've been carrying a waitlist mindset…
- How are consultants actually getting their first 10 clients? · Grow · question · 1 reply
Not the advice version — the real version. Almost nobody's first ten come from content, ads or a funnel. They come from people who already knew…
- Retainer client work: how do you actually get the next one? · Grow · poll
I run a small retainer shop for personal brands in Port Harcourt and most of my work still comes from people who already know me. I…
- Group programme is full but I keep saying yes to 1:1 — how do I actually close that door? · Grow · discussion · 5 replies · solved
Berlin, career coach here. I run a group programme that's at 14 people and I want to take it to 20. The problem is 1:1 keeps…
- How do you actually get attendees for a self-paced course? · Grow · poll
Refilwe has a self-paced course running and a small team, but leads arrive in unpredictable bursts and she can't tell which channel is doing the work.…
- Quick poll: which follow-up actually converts? · Grow · poll
I'm trying to improve conversion on my retainer enquiries, and I suspect the problem is my follow-up rather than my pitch. Before I change anything I…
Go deeper
Reference pages that cover the practical side of this topic.
Browse every public discussion
Building a business around what you know?
The Network is free to join. Ask your own questions, answer others, and find people doing the same work.
See the Network