I'm testing a membership before I build the real thing. Small paid cohort, one shared workspace, and I've cut it from nine tools to three so I can see whether people stay once the novelty wears off. My suspicion is it was never the tools — it was that I kept adding them instead of letting a group form. Ask me in four weeks and I'll tell you straight whether it held.
Testing a paid member area to see if anyone actually logs in
Loading experiment…
In brief
Gavin Gagnon opened an experiment in Proof & Progress, about experiments: I'm testing a membership before I build the real thing. Small paid cohort, one shared workspace, and I've cut it from nine tools to three so I can see whether people stay once the novelty wears off. No replies yet.
No replies yet
Audience: Public. Replies follow this audience.
Explore this topic
This experiment sits in Proof & Progress, which holds 936 conversations. Evidence of what works: wins, experiments, lessons learned, build-in-public updates and case breakdowns.
Related discussions
- Testing a paid workshop to see if my quiet list actually buys · Proof & Progress · experiment
My list is 400 people who read everything and buy nothing. So I'm running a paid workshop at €90 instead of launching another retainer, mostly to…
- Testing who actually opens the paid newsletter · Proof & Progress · experiment
Before I change anything about the format, I want to know if the drop-off is at the open or at the read. I'm splitting next month's…
- Testing a paid office hours slot to see if my quiet audience buys · Proof & Progress · experiment
My list is 3,400 people who read everything and buy nothing. So instead of another launch I put up a €45/month 'office hours' Slack tier for…
- Tested a paid workshop to see if my list buys anything · Proof & Progress · experiment
Six of us on the call, three were past clients. Nobody bought the follow-up offer. I'm starting to think my list is full of people who…
- Testing a paid diagnostic call instead of a free one · Proof & Progress · experiment
I'm trying this on myself before I recommend it to anyone. My list opens emails and never books, so I stopped offering a free intro call…
- Testing a paid onboarding call on new retainers · Proof & Progress · experiment
I want to separate two things before I trust any fix: whether new retainer clients actually need hand-holding, or whether my onboarding process just creates it.…
- Testing a $9/mo paid newsletter tier for my IP licensing readers · Proof & Progress · experiment
I've got the same problem as a lot of you — five tools that each do 15% of the job. So instead of adding a sixth…
- Testing a lower price on my newsletter's monthly plan to see if churn drops · Proof & Progress · experiment
Churn on my paid newsletter has been creeping up and I honestly can't tell if it's price, content, or people just drifting off. So this month…
Go deeper
Reference pages that cover the practical side of this topic.
Browse every public discussion
Building a business around what you know?
The Network is free to join. Ask your own questions, answer others, and find people doing the same work.
See the Network