Experiments discussions
Experiments run in a small business: the change, the result and what to watch. 460 conversations carry this tag across 1 space.
Read the answers members gave, compare how different businesses handled the same decision, and open any thread to see who replied and what they based it on.
Most useful threads on experiments
- First metric when the list opens but nobody buys · Proof & Progress · discussion · 3 replies
We have an email list that opens, a lead magnet that gets downloaded, and two checkout fixes already shipped. Still flat. I don't have time for a dashboard—I need one…
- Put a plain email capture in front of the newsletter for 30 days · Proof & Progress · experiment
Trying something small on the audience problem. Instead of pushing people to a paid signup page, I've added a single free-email field on the two pages where nonprofit comms people…
- Test: 20 minutes of unbooked time before each discovery call · Proof & Progress · experiment
I've been trying to win back time by stacking calls back to back, and I think it's quietly making the leads problem worse. So this month I'm blocking 20 minutes…
- Trying a WhatsApp nudge before each live class · Proof & Progress · experiment
My completion rate has been quietly embarrassing me for months. I think the drop-off happens between sessions, not during them, so I'm testing a short WhatsApp reminder the evening before…
- Trying a 5-question intake at signup instead of a call · Proof & Progress · experiment
I have 11 members and on every new signup I end up on WhatsApp for two days before I know what they actually want. So this month I'm replacing the…
All 460 experiments threads
- Tested charging for the diagnostic call instead of giving it away · Proof & Progress · experiment
Four people booked when the call was free. I put a €75 fee on it for the last three weeks and two people paid, one of them turned into a…
- Testing a 14-day quiet month to see if churn drops · Proof & Progress · experiment
I've got maybe eleven paying members and a churn number I've been staring at since January. My theory is they leave because I keep adding things to look at, not…
- Trying a £7 price on the newsletter for one month · Proof & Progress · experiment
I have 41 paying subscribers and no way to tell a new buyer why £12 is worth it. So for the next four weeks new signups pay £7 and I…
- Tested: asking buyers to pay before the call · Proof & Progress · experiment
I run a small experiment every month and report it here whether or not it works. This month: a €90 paid intro call for the retainer, refunded against the first…
- Testing a 20-minute weekly edit instead of daily replies · Proof & Progress · experiment
I teach Igbo to adults and the newsletter is paid, so I can't drop the replying. But I read somewhere that batching is the fix and I don't believe it…
- Tested a welcome email sent by hand (n=6) · Proof & Progress · experiment
Six new subs signed up in the last five weeks. Onboarding has been a mess at that volume so I hand-wrote every one: three got a personal 'here's who I…
- Tested a 20-minute onboarding call before module one · Proof & Progress · experiment
I keep losing people in week two and I'd been blaming the modules. So this month I called every new joiner for twenty minutes before they got access, on the…
- Stopped letting onboarding happen to me · Proof & Progress · experiment
I ran a two-week test on my group programme onboarding: instead of a 40-minute call per new member, I sent a short form and a recorded walkthrough, then one 15-minute…
- Tested a fixed-scope intake form to cut calls · Proof & Progress · experiment
Two weeks ago I stopped doing discovery calls for my course-build clients and replaced them with one long intake form. I wanted the hours back. I got them, but I…
- Testing a 3-month upfront option to cut churn · Proof & Progress · experiment
Three of my members asked if they could just pay for the quarter instead of monthly, so I figured that was a signal worth chasing. I've put a quarterly option…
- Experiment: asking two questions after someone finishes the course · Proof & Progress · experiment
I'm trying to raise my course price from €149 to €249 and I've been telling myself the problem is the price. But my follow-up is genuinely bad — people finish…
- Testing paid onboarding call vs free onboarding call · Proof & Progress · experiment
I've been onboarding every new member manually on a free 20-min call, and it eats a full afternoon each week. Before I change anything I want to know if the…
- Testing a two-question intake before the free call · Proof & Progress · experiment
I want to fix this before I touch the price. Right now anyone who DMs me gets a 30-minute free call, and my calendar is full of people who were…
- Tested handing module 3 to my editor — here's what broke · Proof & Progress · experiment
I stopped recording module 3 and gave my editor the outline plus raw footage with no notes from me. Two weeks later I watched the cut with the team and…
- Testing a paid workshop for the people who read but never buy · Proof & Progress · experiment
I'm testing whether the non-buyers are actually a different buyer, not a colder version of my customers. Next month I'm running one paid workshop at €90, announced only to my…
- Tested a ₹499 'members only' note on my best essays · Proof & Progress · experiment
For the last four weeks I put a ₹499 paywall on the second half of my two strongest essays, hoping it would pull the free list into paid. Nobody upgraded…
- Charging the first five what I actually need to charge · Proof & Progress · experiment
I have three paying coaching clients and all three came through people I already knew, which means the price never really got tested. My goal this year is to stop…
- Tested cutting my newsletter to one link per issue · Proof & Progress · experiment
Two issues in. Clicks went up, unsubscribes went up more. Turns out people were reading the links list as the value, not the essay. Going to try one link but…
- Tested a 6-week group program at $390 instead of 1:1 at $140/hr · Proof & Progress · experiment
I've been charging $140 an hour for one-to-one and it's killing me — four clients a week and I'm still not covering the mortgage. So this month I ran a…
- Testing a churn interview on my Accra group programme · Proof & Progress · experiment
I run a 12-week group cohort here in Accra and my churn sits around 22% at month three. Instead of guessing, I'm talking to everyone who joins this intake about…
- Test: one tool for onboarding, one for billing · Proof & Progress · experiment
I'm trying to see if I can get my membership experiment down from six tools to two. I moved onboarding into my course platform and billing into Stripe, and killed…
- Tested a higher price on the next five course buyers · Proof & Progress · experiment
I raised the price by 40% for the next five people who enquired, and told them why: fewer seats, more of my time in the feedback rounds. Two bought without…
- Tested a lower price on my beginner guitar group, and now I'm not sure · Proof & Progress · experiment
I've run a Saturday beginners guitar group for two years at GHS 300 a month, twelve people, always full. This term I dropped it to 200 to see if I…
- Tested a fixed pilot fee instead of hourly for two new clients · Proof & Progress · experiment
Two new retainer clients this month, I quoted a flat pilot fee for the first six weeks instead of my usual hourly. Told both the number before scoping anything, which…
- Testing a smaller first module to fix completions · Proof & Progress · experiment
I've been watching people stall out around week three of our onboarding academy and I'm starting to think the first module is just too big. So this cycle I'm cutting…
- Tested putting my course in front of partner audiences first · Proof & Progress · experiment
I run a short course for educators and my conversion has been sitting low for months. My test this term: stop selling to strangers and instead ask three partner organisations…
- Testing a $9/mo paid newsletter tier for my IP licensing readers · Proof & Progress · experiment
I've got the same problem as a lot of you — five tools that each do 15% of the job. So instead of adding a sixth, I'm spending the next…
- Testing whether a fixed follow-up day beats opportunistic follow-up · Proof & Progress · experiment
My follow-up is opportunistic and I know it. Before I try to fix it I want to separate two variables: whether I follow up at all, and whether the timing…
- Testing a cold-audience ad on a $400 budget to see if I can generate proof · Proof & Progress · experiment
I run sponsorship placements for a few clients but I have nothing concrete to show a new buyer who asks what a cold audience actually does with one. So I…
- I put the price on the landing page and lost a third of my signups · Proof & Progress · experiment
Ran this for six weeks on the newsletter checkout. I'd been hiding £12/month behind a 'See plans' click because I was embarrassed by it. Put the number front and centre…
- Testing a higher price with a smaller cohort · Proof & Progress · experiment
I'm moving the course from €495 to €795 for the next intake and cutting the cohort from 40 to 25. If conversion holds, I make more per hour of my…
- Test: raising price on new clients only, not existing · Proof & Progress · experiment
I am not touching what current clients pay. New people coming in from next week get the higher number, and I keep the old rate for anyone already on my…
- Test: one email per month instead of a weekly blog · Proof & Progress · experiment
I have been publishing weekly blog posts for about eighteen months and they bring in almost nothing. So for the next two months I am killing the blog and sending…
- Test: one niche page for 8 weeks, then measure churn · Proof & Progress · experiment
I have been resisting picking a niche for a year because every time I pick one I talk myself out of it by the following week. So I am running…
- Testing a 2-line follow-up after every lesson · Proof & Progress · experiment
I teach piano to about 40 adults and my follow-up is the weak part — people finish a block and just drift off. I'm trying something small for the next…
- Tested two prices on the same newsletter signup page · Proof & Progress · experiment
I split my signup page so half saw R$29/month and half saw R$49/month, same copy, same traffic source. Ran it for eleven days. The R$49 group converted at about the…
- Splitting my churn cause: is it the course or the handoff? · Proof & Progress · experiment
I've been assuming my churn comes from the course itself, but delivery eating my time might be the real culprit. Before I change anything, I'm trying to separate the two…
- Testing a fixed finish line for my paid ad workshop · Proof & Progress · experiment
I run a six-week paid ads workshop for small business owners and only about a third of the people who pay actually finish it. I think it's because I leave…
- Tested a 3-tier price on my retainer, two clients picked the middle · Proof & Progress · experiment
I run a financial coaching retainer here in Singapore and pricing has always been the fog. So for the last month I quoted new leads from a fixed menu instead…
- Tested a one-question churn survey on new subscribers · Proof & Progress · experiment
Before I let myself redesign onboarding, I wanted to know whether people are leaving because of content or because of billing friction, so I added a single optional question at…
Where it is discussed
- Proof & Progress (460): Evidence of what works: wins, experiments, lessons learned, build-in-public updates and case breakdowns.
